How Holden See Us and why do we get him?

 How Holden See Us and why do we get him?

Holden Caulfield, Scout and the Innocence of Children | by Nafi A | Medium

    In the book of Catcher in the Rye we follow the character Holden Caulfield and his journey across New York. When I finished the book I was wondering about something. When I was reading about Holden's experience, he kept on saying thing to me the reader "You would have loved this" or Holden would say things like "You are like them." Holden even gives us information about his dead brother Allie, the only people who have even heard about this is Jean Gallagher and most likely Holden's old English teacher Mr. Antolini. So, why is it that he trusts us with that information. For this blog post I want to dig deeper about Holdon's trust and vulnerability the reader. 

    For my examples I want to talk about are the fights that Holden gets into. I will start with the Stradlater fight first. Stradlater was one of the people that was kinda "friends" with Holden and was also Holden's roommate. Normally if a protagonist of a book/film got into any confrontation with someone. They would most likely make the character look cool or make them look like still stood strong if they lost. But, in the book Holden makes himself weak and vulnerable to the reader. During the fight Holden says when Stradlater is on top of him I quote: ""Get your lousy knees off my chest," I told him. I was almost bawling. I really was." When I was reading this part of the book I was personally confused. Since, in the beginning of the book Holden was kinda acting tuff like "I know how thing work" kinda tuff. But seeing him like this was kinda weird. Because, it shows how vulnerable his is to us.

    The next fight that Holden gets into is the fight with Maurice who was the person in charge of the prostitute service. For context in the start of this fight happened when Maurice claimed that Holden had to pay 10 dollars and he only paid 5. For this misconception there are many possible reasoning. For the fist reason Holden could be lying to us. I think this moment in the book was when the reader could doubt Holden's liability. But, me personally I think Holden is telling the truth. Don't forget, Holden told us about his brother, and he has hasn't told much people about that story. Also well as my first example of his vulnerability during the Stradlater fight. Back to the fight, Holden gets beaten up again. Kinda like the last Stradlater fight. But, this time I think he win mentally. I don't think that Holden was too concerned about money, since right after the fight with Maurice, he gave $10 to some random nuns who weren't doing charity. Also well, Holden was edging on Maurice.  It was like Holden was saying "Take my money you need it anyways." I think Holden in this fight was taunting Maurice. Still though Holden still shows vulnerability in the fight I quote: "Boy was my voice shaking like hell." We can tell that Holden is scared and that he is showing Vulnerability to the reader.

Overall I think that Holden is a very interesting protagonist to the book. Normally when I read or watch anything in media with a man character, it doesn't always feel like I am getting to know them on a personal level. While reading to book I felt like I was talking to Holden. His personality made it feel like I was having a conversation with him. And I feel like Holden wanted to have a conversation with us too, during the book he said we was lonely and he needed someone to talk too. I think we are that person.

Comments

  1. ElliotthegreatFebruary 5, 2026 at 6:37 PM

    Hi Omarion Dickens, Your analysis of the recurring theme behind every fight that Holden gets himself into and how he gets dog pounded every time and how he shows his vulnerabilities there as well as feeling inclined to tell things about stuff such as his dead brother but also how weird it is because in the beginning to me, it also felt like Holden was this big tough guy with how presented himself and talked the big game but ends up getting beaten up all the time. This analysis gave me a very zesty feeling and it was like biting the inside of a fruit with the juices drippin out: satisfying, juicy and loving. Great Job and Peace God!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie RasmussenFebruary 7, 2026 at 5:49 AM

    I agree that Holden's vulnerability with the reader is an interesting facet of his character. It kind of makes me think about what kind of person he is telling the book to, and how it is that he trusts them and tells it like it is. As the book goes on, he does start telling more people things, but at the start he is very reticent to talk about any of his pent-up feelings with other characters. We can guess that he gets better at talking to people about this in whatever sanatarium he ends up in by the end, but it still seems like if he has this level of honesty with the reader—as you've shown—then, if we intend to write in a character's voice instead of our own, that gives us an exciting task of reverse-engineering or finding a character that Holden trusts so deeply.

    ReplyDelete
  3. MitchellFebruary 11, 2026 at 11:15 AM

    I think it's crucial to point out how vulnerable Holden is willing to make himself, as a narrator, and I agree that this has a LOT to do with how he positions us as the reader--there's an extraordinary sense of trust that develops between narrator and reader, and that likely has a lot to do with how and why this book has resonated with millions of readers over the years. We DO feel like we have this special connection to the narrator, and therefore the book, and maybe also the author. (At one point, Holden refers to wanting to call up the author on the phone, when he really enjoys a book--clearly too many people had this same thought about Salinger!)

    Emphasizing Holden's vulnerability is important, because it can sneak up on a reader: from the start, Holden likes to assume a POSE of invulnerability, total confidence, snarky sarcasm, as if he is untouchable. Quickly we understand that this pose attempts to mask a lot of hurt and confusion, and by the end of the novel, we "know" this boy at a deeper level than anyone else in his life, including Phoebe or Antolini (he talks to US about THEM, but he can't talk to THEM about US).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Olly EarlsFebruary 17, 2026 at 9:08 AM

    Hey Amari! I think it is really interesting that he mentioned feeling more connected to Holden than many masculine characters in media. Holden definitely shares a more intimate relationship to the reader. I feel like this observation goes right back to the point Holden often makes about the phoniness of those around him, and also the crushing loneliness he feels around his peers in school.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The similarities and differences of Matthew Henson and Coalhouse Walker

Image
 The similarities and differences between Matthew Henson and Coalhouse Walker M atthew Henson   Coalhouse Walker Jr..... Matthew Henson, the man who was an assistant to Robert Peary. A historical figure who was a very vital asset to the exploration of the North Pole, but was very easily forgotten. On the other hand, we have Coalhouse Walker.  He is a non-fictional character, yet he stands out so much more that it is hard to forget him while reading Ragtime. They are both African Americans, but one is barely remembered in history. The other one, if a real history figure, in my opinion would be a substantial figure in civil rights. In this blog, I am going to go though the two of the African American figures in ragtime.  First, I would like to talk about Matthew Henson. In the book of Ragtime it shines a light on how Matthew Henson did most of the work during the expedition. Even though he worked so hard, people were jealous of his hard work so for most ...
Read more

Jes Grew an in depth Analysis

Image
Jes Grew an in depth Analysis     In the book Mumbo Jumbo there are a lot of different and unique concepts in the novel. The main plot of this novel is the spread of a "virus" called Jes Grew. Some people call it an "Anti-Virus" because it is non-lethal in any way. Jes Grew is a certain culture growth that effects a country or maybe even effects the world. In the story Jes grew is a development of Black and African culture spreading in America trying to find the text. Overall this concept is very interesting to me. So, for this blog post I want to dive deep into the "Anti-Virus" Jes Grew and anything similar to it.  I would like to First talk about the a similarity to Jes Grew which is in the book Ragtime . In the book Ragtime, there was a character named Coalhouse Walker Jr. and we specialized in Ragtime music. Ragtime music was a mixture of European classical music and then added with African-American rhythms movements and traditions. The growth of Ragti...
Read more

Dana's Effect on Rufus

Dana's Effect on Rufus and Herself      When were first met the character Dana, she was always a kind person. I person who would put herself over others. For example in the chapter the River. When Dana first meets Rufus, who was drowning in the river. Her first thought was to save him from drowning. In that moment I feel like that shows a Character who is kind and cares for other people. In the book Kindred Dana's goal is to make sure Rufus and Alice *her two ancestors* to have a child called Hagar Greenwood. While Dana is on her mission as the kind person she is, she wants to make Rufus into a good slave owner who treats his slaves well. She also wants to make Alice and Rufus get married. Dana wants to be this minor observer who just experiences and adjusts from the shadows of the past. But how long can Dana keep observing until see is part of the system. Since her "observing" is her pretending to be a slave in the plantation. Later on all of the pretending that Dana...
Read more